The Rolex Explorer II is a legendary watch, known for its ruggedness, reliability, and distinctive 24-hour bezel. If you're considering adding one to your collection, you might be weighing the pros and cons of the modern 216570 against its predecessor, the 16570. Both are fantastic watches, but they have distinct characteristics that cater to different preferences. Let's dive deep into a head-to-head comparison to help you decide which Explorer II is the perfect fit for you.

A Detailed Look at the Rolex Explorer II 216570

Let's kick things off by focusing on the Rolex Explorer II 216570. This model, produced from 2011 to 2021, brought a significant update to the Explorer II line. One of the first things you'll notice is its size. The 216570 boasts a 42mm case, a step up from the 16570's 40mm. This larger size gives it a more substantial presence on the wrist, catering to the modern trend of larger watches. The increased size isn't just for show; it also improves legibility, which is crucial for a tool watch designed for exploration. Speaking of legibility, the 216570 features a highly visible Chromalight display, with blue luminescence that glows brightly in low-light conditions. This makes it incredibly easy to read the time, even in the darkest environments.

Under the hood, the 216570 houses Rolex's caliber 3187 movement. This is a robust and reliable movement with a parachrom hairspring, offering greater resistance to shocks and temperature variations. It also features a longer power reserve compared to the 16570, giving you approximately 48 hours of runtime. The 216570 also brought back the iconic orange 24-hour hand, a nod to the original Explorer II 1655. This adds a pop of color and enhances the watch's overall aesthetic appeal. The fixed 24-hour bezel allows you to track a second time zone, a practical feature for travelers. The 216570 Rolex Explorer II is a modern take on a classic, offering a blend of ruggedness, functionality, and contemporary styling. Its larger size, improved legibility, and advanced movement make it a compelling choice for those who want a modern Explorer II. The 216570 has been discontinued and replaced by the 226570, so if you want this specific model, the secondary market is the only way to obtain this model.

Examining the Rolex Explorer II 16570

Now, let's turn our attention to the Rolex Explorer II 16570. Produced from 1989 to 2011, this model represents a significant period in the Explorer II's history. One of the defining characteristics of the 16570 is its 40mm case size. This more compact size makes it a comfortable fit for a wider range of wrist sizes. Some people will prefer this size of the more modern larger size of the Rolex Explorer II 216570. While it might not have the same wrist presence as the 216570, the 16570 offers a more classic and understated look. The Rolex Explorer II 16570 is also noticeably slimmer than the 216570, which further enhances its comfort. Over its production run, the 16570 was powered by two different movements: the caliber 3085 and later the caliber 3185. Both movements are known for their reliability and accuracy. However, the 3185 is generally considered to be an improvement over the 3085, offering a more refined timekeeping experience.

Unlike the 216570's Chromalight display, the 16570 features tritium or Luminova luminous material on its dial and hands, depending on the year it was produced. Tritium dials will develop a unique patina over time, adding to the watch's vintage charm. However, tritium's luminosity fades over time, so older 16570s may not be as bright as newer watches. The 16570 also features a fixed 24-hour bezel that allows you to track a second time zone. The 24-hour hand on earlier models was painted red, while later models featured a white gold surround. The 16570 Rolex Explorer II is a versatile and timeless watch that offers a blend of classic styling and reliable performance. Its smaller size, comfortable fit, and vintage appeal make it a compelling choice for those who appreciate a more understated Explorer II.

Head-to-Head Comparison: 216570 vs. 16570

To make things clearer, let's break down the key differences between the Rolex Explorer II 216570 and 16570 in a head-to-head comparison:

• Case Size: The 216570 boasts a 42mm case, while the 16570 has a more compact 40mm case.
• Luminescence: The 216570 features a bright Chromalight display, while the 16570 uses tritium or Luminova, depending on the year.
• Movement: The 216570 is powered by the caliber 3187 movement, while the 16570 uses either the caliber 3085 or 3185.
• 24-Hour Hand: The 216570 features an orange 24-hour hand, while the 16570 has a red or white hand, depending on the year.
• Wrist Presence: The 216570 has a more substantial presence on the wrist due to its larger size, while the 16570 offers a more classic and understated look.
• Modernity: The 216570 Explorer II is the more modern of the two, with its larger size, updated movement, and improved luminescence.
• Vintage Appeal: The 16570 Explorer II has a more vintage appeal, especially older models with tritium dials that have developed a unique patina.

Aesthetics and Wearability

Beyond the technical specifications, the aesthetic differences between the 216570 and 16570 are significant. The 216570 presents a bolder, more contemporary look. Its larger case size and the vibrant orange 24-hour hand immediately catch the eye. The Chromalight display provides a modern, highly legible glow in dark conditions. The overall impression is one of a robust, modern tool watch designed for adventure.

On the other hand, the 16570 exudes a more classic and understated charm. Its smaller case size and slimmer profile make it incredibly comfortable to wear, even for those with smaller wrists. The tritium or Luminova lume provides a more subtle glow, and the potential for a tritium dial to develop a patina adds a unique vintage character. The 16570 feels like a versatile, timeless watch that can be dressed up or down. The watch's weight distribution is also different due to the case sizes. The 16570 will feel lighter and more snug on your wrist.

Movement and Functionality

The movements powering these two Explorer II models are both reliable and accurate, but they have some key differences. The 216570's caliber 3187 is a more modern movement with a parachrom hairspring, offering greater resistance to shocks and temperature variations. It also has a longer power reserve of approximately 48 hours. This means you can take the watch off on Friday evening and it will still be running on Sunday morning.

The 16570's caliber 3085 or 3185 movements are also highly regarded, but they don't have the same level of shock resistance or power reserve as the 3187. However, they are still incredibly reliable and accurate timekeepers. Both watches feature a fixed 24-hour bezel and a 24-hour hand, allowing you to track a second time zone. This is a practical feature for travelers or anyone who needs to keep track of time in another part of the world. Whether you prefer the more modern movement of the 216570 or the reliable vintage movement of the 16570, you can be confident that both watches will provide accurate and dependable timekeeping.

Price and Availability

When considering the Rolex Explorer II 216570 and 16570, price and availability are important factors. Since both models are discontinued, you'll need to turn to the secondary market to acquire one. Prices can vary depending on condition, age, and whether or not the watch comes with its original box and papers. Generally, the 216570 tends to command a higher price than the 16570 due to its more modern features and larger size. However, the price difference can fluctuate depending on market demand. Availability can also vary. The 16570, having been produced for a longer period, is generally easier to find on the secondary market. However, pristine examples of either model can be challenging to locate. Be sure to do your research and buy from a reputable source to ensure you're getting an authentic watch in good condition.

Which Explorer II is Right for You?

Ultimately, the choice between the Rolex Explorer II 216570 and 16570 comes down to personal preference. If you prefer a larger, more modern watch with enhanced legibility and a robust movement, the 216570 is an excellent choice. Its bold design and contemporary features make it a standout piece. If you appreciate a more classic and understated watch with a comfortable fit and vintage appeal, the 16570 is a great option. Its timeless design and reliable performance make it a versatile addition to any collection. Consider your wrist size, your personal style, and your budget when making your decision. Both the Rolex Explorer II 216570 and 16570 are exceptional watches that will provide years of enjoyment.

No matter which Explorer II you choose, you'll be getting a legendary watch with a rich history and a reputation for excellence. Happy hunting!